/
2020-07-15 - [CNTT - RM Workstream Master] Agenda and Meeting Minutes

Anuket Project

2020-07-15 - [CNTT - RM Workstream Master] Agenda and Meeting Minutes

Jul 22, 2020

Attendees:

Please add your name in here:

  •  

    • @Walter.kozlowski (Telstra)

    • @Pankaj.Goyal (AT&T)

    • @Suresh Krishnan (Deactivated) (Kaloom)

    • @Ulrich Kleber (Huawei)

    • @Tom Van Pelt (Deactivated) (GSMA)

    • @Tomas Fredberg (Ericsson) (Ericsson)

    • @Sukhdev Kapur (Juniper)

    • @Petar Torre (Deactivated) (Intel)

    • @Ahmed El Sawaf (stc)

    • @Former user (Deleted) (VF)

    • @Tomas Fredberg (Ericsson) (E//)

    • @Per Andersson  (Kaloom)

Special Notes:



  • Weekly RM meetings are intended to

    • Plan RM and Network related work

    • Identify owners for new Issues/PRs

    • Track open Issues/PRs

    • Address technical issues that cannot be resolved online (i.e. resolve stalls)

Agenda:

Chapter.Section

Content

Issues

Owner

Comments

Chapter 0

From https://github.com/cntt-n/CNTT/tree/master/doc/tech#4.0

Cloud iNfrastructure Telco Taskforce wiki document

As per GSMA feedback, need to add CNTT intro

Walter

@Former user (Deleted) to put into the doc root directory as Chapter 0, and do updates

https://github.com/cntt-n/CNTT/blob/master/doc/common/chapter00.md#4.0

Chapter 1

Address issues

GSMA feedback

Issues: 1542, 1321

Walter

Issue #1464 moved to Ch03

#1542 closed

#1321 fixed, closed

Reformatted to align with the GSMA feedback, PR #1750, MERGED and CLOSED

Chapter 2

Address issues

GSMA feedback

Issues:

Walter

Ahmed to move uses case to sec 2.2 (Issue # 1751)

GSMA feedback addressed in PR# 1752, MERGED and CLOSED



Chapter 3

Address issues

Content for 3.5

GSMA feedback

Issues: 1645, 195, 183, 1464

Walter

Changes to Introductory text for Chapter 3 addressed in PR#1780 for team review and approval/merge (relates to Issue # 1645 and GSMA feedback) - APPROVED

Section 3.1 changes addressed in PR#1787 for team review and approval/merge (relates to Issue # 1645 and GSMA feedback) - Reviewed/Updated, ready for RE-REVIEW / RE-APPROVAL

Section 3.2 changes addressed in PR#1781 for team review and approval/merge (relates to Issue # 1645 and GSMA feedback, and closing Issue #1464) -2 APPROVALS, NEED 1 MORE

Section 3.3, 3.4, 3.5 changes addressed in PR#1789 for team review and approval/merge (relates to Issue # 1645 and GSMA feedback-2 APPROVALS, NEED 1 MORE

Section 3.6 on model realization (new) added; PR #1796 for REVIEW

All of which also include the updated png file in the /figure

Closing Issue #1645

Issue #1464 moved from Ch01

Issue #183: Bonding, ACP, Redundancy - no reason in Chapter 3?

Issue #195: Intra-networking: how much do we need in Chapter3?



Chapter 4.1, 4.2

Address issues



GSMA feedback

Issues: 816, 308, 1582, 958, 957, 678, 250,        

Ahmed

Issue  #816 PR#1756 fixes this issues to be resolved by @Gergely Csatari and merged

Issue to be opened by @Gergely Csatari to add two exceptions to Appendix A.3 and later 4.2 to be corrected with the reference to these exceptions

RM Table 4-11 (metrics) in Section 4.1.6.1 Resources Management Measurements https://github.com/cntt-n/CNTT/blob/master/doc/ref_model/chapters/chapter04.md#4161-resources-management-measurements  for REVIEW by the team

Chapter 4.3

Network, new content

GSMA feedback

Issues: 1644,587

Tomas

PR#1771

Closing Issue #1644

Chapter 5.1, 5.2 (software)

Address issues



GSMA feedback

Issues: 163, 816, 143, 1466

Pankaj

Issues 1465, 1583 closed (removed form this list). Issue 1466 – proposal to close

Issue  #816 (consistency and typos) PR#1756 fixes this issues to be resolved by @Gergely Csatari and merged

Chapter 5.3, 5.4 (Hardware)

Address issues



GSMA feedback

Issues: 163, 816, 143,

Karine

Issue  #816 PR#1756 fixes this issues to be resolved by @Gergely Csatari and merged

Chapter 6

Address issues



GSMA feedback

Issues:

Pankaj

Sec 6.1 to be reviewed by @Walter.kozlowski, and others

One GSMA issue – related to the old md Table. Need Tom to confirm if still an issue with the new HTML Table format.

Chapter 7

Security

Rewrite, address issues

GSMA feedback

Issues: 1508, 1507, 1506,1505, 1504, 1503, 366, 1758, 1754, 1755

Karine

@Karine Sevilla reviewed the issues;

Issue # 1758 to be converted to PR

Chapter 8

Conformance, Verification, and Certification



Issue: 216

Walter

Agreed at TSC to remove title "Conformance, Verification, and Certification" and leave this Chapter blank for now

Done in PR# 1742, closed

Chapter 9

LCM

Address issues



GSMA feedback

Issues:1251, 365, 663, 586

Walter



Chapter 10.3.1

Discovery

New content

Issue: 1688

Sukhdev

Please remove the relevant gap from RA-1

Issue #1768 and PR#1769

Chapter 10.3.2

Load balancing

New content

Issue: 1689

Per

Please remove the relevant gap from RA-1

Issue #1768 and PR#1769

Chapter 10.3.3

Service Function Chain

New content

Issue: 1690

Suresh

Please remove the relevant gap from RA-1

Issue #1768 and PR#1769

PR# 1798 for REVIEW

Chapter 10.3.4

Packet acceleration

New content

Issue: 1691

Suresh

Please remove the relevant gap from RA-1

Issue #1768 and PR#1769

PR# 1798 for REVIEW

Chapter 10.3

New gap

New content

Issue: 255

Pankaj

Please remove the relevant gap from RA-1

Issue #255 – no content added related to the issue in RA-1 Ch08.

Appendix A

Address issues



GSMA feedback

Issues:1306, 1459

Walter



Overall editing

Address issues



GSMA feedback

Issues:1625, 1598, 1359, 1677 (GSMA),

Walter



Overall topics for Baraque (per Rabi’s plan)









Networking Modelling

Review RM and add/update content



Tomas



Networking & Storage Characterization

Review RM and add/update content



Karine

Petar

Chapter 2, storage profile defined review needed.

Section 3.2.3 Storage needs review

Full Containerization support

Review RM and add/update content



Walter



HW Acceleration support

Review RM and add/update content

Issue: 155, 1659

Ahmed



Edge

Review RM and add/update content

Issue: 1659, 1722, 1719

Ahmed



Actions:

Minutes:

  • We keep the current style numbering, subject to cleanup.