2022-05-16- [Anuket RA-1]- Workstream Meeting Agenda and Minutes

Anuket Project

2022-05-16- [Anuket RA-1]- Workstream Meeting Agenda and Minutes

Meetings Every Monday at 14:30 UTC

Zoom Meeting link: https://zoom.us/j/99279174971?pwd=eWozNENnYkpLSXdRSzZvblNKVU1wdz09

Attendees:

  • Name (Organisation) |  will incorporate Participant report from Zoom.

Name

Name

@Pankaj.Goyal(Microsoft)

@Karine Sevilla(Orange)

@Ildiko (Open Infra)

@Cédric Ollivier (Orange)

 

As a courtesy to your colleagues please mute yourself when in listen mode. Thanks

Antitrust Policy

This meeting is held in accordance with the LFN and GSMA anti-trust policies.

https://r.lfnetworking.org/Antitrust%20Slide.pdf and GSMA Anti-Trust Policy Notice

Agenda and Minutes

  1. Agenda Bashing

  2. Release information

  3. GSMA document structure 

  4. Rst conversion status

  5. PRs review

  6. Review of detailled issues for Moselle

  7. Proposals for LFN event in Porto 

  8. Next Meetings

  9.  AOB

Release information

  • New Moselle Release milestones approved by the TSC on 19th of April

 

Milestone(Official)

GitHub

Date

Notes

Milestone(Official)

GitHub

Date

Notes

M1 

 

2022-02-01

Release definition

M2

 

2022-03-22

Scope freeze

M3 (Software project only, not for specs)

 

2022-05-03

RC valid. testing

M4

M3

2022-05-24

Content freeze

M4-s

M4

2022-06-07

Proofreading

M5

 

2022-06-07

Release readiness

M6

 

2022-06-14

Sign off

 

Moselle Specification Planning Dashboard - RA1

GSMA document structure

Issues to generate the following tables:

  • Terminology: switch from "ref" to "include" on RST 

  • Abbreviation/Acronym: A new table must be created in RST and manually edited, with "include" instruction 

  • References and bibliography: 2 tables to be created, add the references inside the text manually. Proposal from Pankaj to create 1 RST file with 2 tables(References, Bibliography) with references and numbering in sequence (no redundant number), example . Start ASAP and finalise during proofreading period.

  • Tables of requirements: on traceability column, 3 options : keep only name title on RST,  Keep name and links for RST and GSMA, post process to remove links on GSMA → Decision to keep name and links to RTD on GSMA document

RST conversion

First step: md files cleaning is done, PR #2766 merged

RST files are generated and uploaded, PR #2799, merged, 

RST cleaning following rst conversion:

  • Ch01 and Ch02, PR#2811: reference links fixed → merged

  • Ch03, Ch04, PR#2815: reference links fixed , Figures captions, Lines breaks →merged

  • Ch05, PR#2817: Addition of backslashes to fix cut words → merged

  • Ch02 , PR#2821: Addition of backslashes to fix cut words → merged

  • Ch07, PR#2819: duplicated title removed → merged

  • Ch08, PR#2820: numbering removed for internal link→ merged

  • Ch06, PR#2818: reference links fixed, tables fixed → merged

Tox issues on RST files: PR#2830 -> merged

First start page for all Anuket specs, PR#2845 → merged

Tox added, links modified, tables format modified, PR#2856 → merged

 Configuration of figures numbering format, PR#2893 → merged

Ongoing RST : Figures caption and references to figures number, for all chapters

Tables Chapter 2: PR#2911 merged

PR #2926: wrap chap2 tables (continued) → merged

PR#2946: Tables formats, switch to list-table directive → merged

RA1 contributors agree to switch to list-table format, conversion to do for all the tables 

All: help needed to format tables: Tables in chapter 2, Pankaj  will take care of chapter 2 tables.

During proofreading period, we will change the table format to list-table for the other chapters.

PR#2959: tables formats +  linkcheck → merged

PR#2964: Tables formats changed (Chapters 3 and 4)

PRs review

PR#2962: Link RA Start page (readme or index?). This should be consistent across all Anuket Streams and should be discussed at a global level to adopt a common structure for all sub-projects.

PR#2964: Ch03/Ch04 Cloud Topology. Tables format changed to list. Warning: Tab needed before * (alignment with list-table) and blank char must be deleted in case of empty content. Cédric will take care of the errors.

PR#2971: Automation and installers, reviews needed

Issues review

 

Issue #

Deliverable

Comments

Issue #

Deliverable

Comments

2787

Storage

  • Chapter 3 (issue #2860)

 Expand the section "Virtual storage" highlighting the storage requirements for workloads and for the infrastructure components. Refer to RM chapter 3.

On the "Cloud Topology" section, describe the differences per hosting environments: large DC to edge infrastructures, in conjunction with RM Chapter 3, 3.6.4. Storage scenarios and architecture fit.

  • Chapter 4 (issue #2861)

Develop on interactions between OpenStack Cinder/Swift and storage backends.

Add examples of backend solutions.

  • Hyperconverged storage for Edge (ssue #2874)

2732

Specification references updates 

  • Chapter 2: add specification content references into requirements' tables (issue #2877)

  • By chapters: add requirements references matching content 

2500

Edge

  • Collect requirements and characteristics from existing production deployments ( Chapters 2 & 4) (issue #2500). It is linked with RM content for chapter "API"

  • Partially addressed by PR#2964

2775

Cloud Topology

Content improvement (issue #2775):

  • Chapter 04: Cloud Topology and Control plane scenarios, in table 4-5,  "*" and "**" need to be defined 

2786

Acceleration

  • Development on acceleration focusing on use cases. Identify the acceleration needs and technologies for workloads hosted in Data Centre and for workloads deployed at the edge (#2786)

2784

Hybrid and multi cloud

  • Hybrid multi-cloud orchestration (#2784)

  • Evaluate other communities: ONAP, GSMA OPG, ...  (#2784) (New CAMARA LF project)

2776

Automation 

  • Lifecycle Automation: align with RM development on automation (issue #2238)

  • Deployment automation: give more guidance (issue #2776)

 

RST conversion

  • Creation of rst files and removal of md files (issue #2796) closed

  • Add name to all figures reused by the other streams(issue#2872)

 

GSMA doc

  • Add metadata to automate GSMA doc creation (issue#2609)

For cloud topology, at this stage, we do not see how to add diagram to describe the redundancy  models; The redundancy models are already described in topology details.

(Chapter 03: Topology overview, make clearer the redundancy models, eventually with high level diagrams)

Issue #2775, Pankaj: Clarification by deletion of titles and text modification

Issue #2784, Karine: For hybrid and multi-cloud orchestration, The OMNI project is not a good candidate, the project is no more active. The scope of GSMA OPG project is on services and not relevant for RA1. CAMARA is too young to provide real inputs for RA1. This issue cannot be addresed for Moselle and will be closed.

Proposals for LFN event in Porto:

RA1: Moselle updates and discussion for Nile release (new OpenStack release?)

RM, RA1 and RA2 joint session on automation and LCM

Next meetings

2022-05-23:  next meeting

Actions

Name

Action

Name

Action

All

Review PRs

Joël 

To have a look on Storage

All 

Need to find more contributror on acceleration

Karine

Check the table on security controls edited by CNCF, add the reference into RM and RAs

Karine

Provide content for storage

Meeting Recording: none